Примеры использования Invalidity of a reservation на Английском языке и их переводы на Русский язык
{-}
-
Official
-
Colloquial
Consequences of the invalidity of a reservation.
It was for the State parties to determine the validity and the consequences of the invalidity of a reservation.
At the same time, the invalidity of a reservation generally invalidated ratification of the treaty itself.
It was underlined that no distinction should be made, in that context, between the various grounds for invalidity of a reservation.
The consequences of the invalidity of a reservation.
However, the invalidity of a reservation could not lead to the assumption that the treaty was fully binding on the reserving State.
In other words, neither article 20 norarticle 21 set out the consequences of the invalidity of a reservation, at least not expressly.
The invalidity of a reservation could not lead to the assumption that the treaty was fully binding on the State in question.
The main objection stated that the guideline was impracticable due to the lack of an objective mechanism for determining the validity or invalidity of a reservation.
Together with draft guideline 3.3.3,it demonstrated that the validity or invalidity of a reservation was directly related to the objective elements of treaty law and was not a subjective decision on the part of States.
However, we accept that this position is challenged by the practical difficulties as to where,when or by whom the impermissibility or invalidity of a reservation is established.
Furthermore, the alleged invalidity of a reservation may be challenged by an objection, while the possibility of reacting to an objection, the effects of which may be considered as exceeding the right to object, appears doubtful.
Nullity, which was the penalty for invalidity in domestic law, did not appear to be an appropriate outcome of the invalidity of a reservation in international law.
On the other hand, her delegation did not see how the supposed intrinsic invalidity of a reservation could prevent States from accepting it or what was the practical effect of preventing such acceptance from changing the nullity of the reservation. .
He hoped that the International Law Commission would agree with the Special Rapporteur when the time came to finalize the text on legal consequences of the invalidity of a reservation.
On the other hand, it was not obvious how the supposed intrinsic invalidity of a reservation could prevent States from accepting it or what the practical effect of preventing such acceptance from changing the nullity of the reservation was.
Nullity, which was the penalty for invalidity in domestic law,did not appear to be an appropriate outcome of the invalidity of a reservation in international law.
Furthermore, the alleged invalidity of a reservation might be challenged by an objection, while the possibility of reacting to an objection, the effects of which might be considered as exceeding the right to object, appeared doubtful.
Her delegation supported the intention of the drafters of guideline 3.3.1 to remove any remaining ambiguity as to the effects of the invalidity of a reservation.
The last section of the tenth report deals with the consequences of the invalidity of a reservation, a matter that constituted one of the most serious gaps on the topic in the Vienna Conventions, which were silent on that point, whether deliberately or otherwise.
One of the most sensitive aspects of the draft guidelines was the definition of the object andpurpose of a treaty for the purposes of determining the validity or invalidity of a reservation.
In the same vein, the Commission has already recognized, in guideline 2.3.1, that the invalidity of a reservation owing to its late formulation may be remedied by unanimous acceptance-- or at least absence of objection-- by all the contracting States and contracting organizations.
The travaux préparatoires on the provisions of these two Conventions that concern reservations are equally unrevealing as to the effects-- or lack thereof-- that result from the invalidity of a reservation.
The fact that States could determine the invalidity of a reservation reflected the consensual nature of legal norms, but since such a procedure could lead to disagreement between the parties to a treaty, it was essential that treaties should include clear dispute settlement provisions and, where appropriate, establish a monitoring or depositary body to determine the validity of the reservation. .
The commentary to the draft guidelines indicates that section 4.5 establishes an objective regime for assessing the invalidity of a reservation which is not dependent upon the reactions of other States.
Finally, to alleviate the doubts of Mr. Wang Xuexian, Mr. Camara recalled that the working group had stressed very firmly that it was necessary to demonstrate flexibility with regard to the consequences to be drawn from the invalidity of a reservation.
According to a different view, the relative character of the assessment of the validity of reservations should be recognized, andit should also be clarified that the solution retained in draft guideline 4.5.1 was only applicable when the invalidity of a reservation had been assessed by a third party through a decision that was binding on all contracting States and organizations.
One especially complex matter, dealt with in draft guideline 3.1.6, was that of determining the object and purpose of a treaty,which was the basis for determining the validity or invalidity of a reservation.
The third part of the Guide to Practice dealt successively with the permissibility of reservations, competence to assess the validity of reservations and the consequences of the invalidity of a reservation.
Indeed, it is in every respect very important for States and international organizations to formulate an objection,when they deem it justified, in order to state publicly their position on the invalidity of a reservation.